Would You Prefer To See Stamp Duty Abolished Up To £250 000 And Savings Tax Abolished Altogether?

by , 8 months agoOpen Question

This would kick start the economy from the lower end of the housing market is being held back and people's cost of living is continously going upwards.

Answers (3)

I'd prefer to see stamp duty staggered rather than the current system where it's 0% up to £175K (or £250K if you're a FTB) but 1% of the total value over this. It should be 0% up to £250K, 2.5% of the value between 200,001 and 500,000 then 5% from 500,001 to 750,000 then 10% on 750,001+. Make the wealthy pay proportionately more while allowing low and middle income workers afford their homes.

by G-Man, 8 months ago

Noticed a typo: "... but 1% of the total value *if* over this"

TBH I can't decide if 0% up to £200K or £250K is best. I think on balance, it should be 0% up to the average house price (currently around £170K) and maybe use multiples of the average house price e.g. 0% of first £170K, 2.5% of 170-370, 5% of 370-540, 7.5% of 540-710 etc.

by G-Man, 8 months ago

I agree with G-Man. It also seems daft to me that you pay the tax on the whole amount. Our last house, which we're renting out at the moment, is worth round about £250K and we know we have to go under that price as the stamp duty will kick in otherwise. So nothing much is going to sell for between 250 and 300K. Once you hit that level you'd be more likely to accept the increase in the stamp duty.

by roseangel, 8 months ago

Hmm. Might have just changed my mind a lot. How about:

1) Abolish stamp duty and land regristration tax

2) Abolish all tax breaks relating to the sale of property and its renting out

3) Re-align CGT with income tax

So...

a) No one pays tax on a purchase, but they do pay on a sale - which makes sense as asking for taxes when someone has no money as they've just bought a house is silly, it's better to request tax payment after a house has sold.

b) Rich people don't pay 18% CGT rather than 50% income tax.

c) Landlords don't duck tax by matching rents with interest payments while taking their cash tax-free by re-mortgaging to extract equity.

by G-Man, 8 months ago

Interesting thoughts G-Man but your first submision was probably much fairer.CGT was reduced drastically from 40% to 18% a few years ago by the last Government, so I can't see people accepting pushing it back up to 50%.

by creativesaver, 8 months ago

Posts within the money.co.uk community represent the views, experiences and opinions of members only. They should not be taken as financial advice and should not be followed without further research.

Get our free money saving newsletter
Join over 480,000 other subscribers who grab our expert money tips, unmissable money guides & hottest bargains each week in our special email...

More Questions for Stamp Duty

Closed Questions
Join Our Community

Get fast answers to your money questions, Expert insight, top tips & much more...