Why you should be careful when using a Bank's service in drawing up your will!

by , 1 year agoOpen Question

This was mentioned on Radio 5 Live Money programme the other morning. A number of banks who offer a 'making a will service' often make themselves a legal executor and this means that they are able to takes fees off the overall estate. Bloody cheek!

Answers (12)

Nobody can 'make themselves' executor, only the person whose will it is can appoint executor/s. Presumably, what you mean is that some banks SUGGEST you make them an executor...the simple answer to that is to say 'no thankyou'.

by fruitcake, 1 year ago

Quite right. Even solicitors may suggest that you make them executors, it's not just banks. But as fruitcake says, just say no thanks.

by roseangel, 1 year ago

I have had my local solicitor to do my will,also iv,e signed my house over to both my children,and yes there is a fee for the solicitor doing the work,if anything happens to me,but the cost is on the overall estate,but cos iv,e alresdy signed the property to my children and the deeds are in both their names already,the cost will be very little.Worth thinking about if your mortgage is cleared.

by blondie, 1 year ago

You need to be very careful about doing that. They now have the right to sell the house from under you and you would not be able to stop them.They may not do it maliciously but their circumstances may force it, you never know.

by roseangel, 1 year ago

If it,s done with a period of over 7 years since signed over,the solicitor said very difficult to take property.Mine has been over that 7 years.

by blondie, 1 year ago

I hope you're right. I'll have to look into that.

by roseangel, 1 year ago

Icouldn.t agree more ryancarte.

by blondie, 1 year ago

I don't think banks should be able to offer this service. Leave it to the solicitors, let them do their job. There was a report in the paper about tesco offering legal advice including wills and I completely disagree with it. Just let the solicitors do it, get it done properly and then you don't have to think about it.

by ryancarte, 1 year ago

I couldn,t agree more ryancarte.

by blondie, 1 year ago

surely you would spot this though? im sorry but wills are easy to draw up why you even bother going to a bank, who lets be honest cant be trusted anyway! i feel sorry for little old lady types who might be bullied into this but other than them and if there is anybody who might benefit from the will it should be them looking out for the said little old lady in the first place or they dont deserve to profit. that might be abit unsympathetic...

by katkity, 1 year ago

Remember that you should never seek any financial advice from a Bank or Building Society, and never ever let a solicitor be an executor to your will they just write lots of letters and charge thousands

by Roger, 1 year ago

I believe a lot of solicitors do the same thing. They don't make any money on the £50 or £100 they charge for making the will, they are all expecting larger rewards for being the executor. However, that is their job so why not if you don't have an alternative. Actually I believe its better if you use a solicitor to be executor to ensure your requirements are carried out correctly.

by donk, 1 year ago

Totally agree. I need to rewrite my will and will be asking trusted family members to be the executors. If you detail out exactly what you want to happen and who to have what then they can ensure what your want to happen does.

by laura, 1 year ago

That is cheeky, is there no depths the money grabbing fatcats will stoop to? It's probably better to use a solicitor anyway as they are specialised in these matters.

by MarkX, 1 year ago

As I am considering a DIY will anyway I was going to ask my brother to be executor. I certainly don't want to pay either banks or solicitors to execute it on my behalf.

by frenchwoodgirl, 1 year ago

I understand what your saying,but as my solicitor told me that a friend of his done a diy will and had his sister to be his executor,sadly his sister had a car accident and died before him.Therefore it eventualy had to go to a solicitor to sort it all out, and cost a lot more,than it would have in the first place, cos had to trace rest of family.

by blondie, 1 year ago

I do have a sister too if the worst were to happen. I would pick my brother as he is probably better at sorting out financial matters like this, but a good point though.

by frenchwoodgirl, 1 year ago

I think that is part of the reason they ask you to name two executors of a will, then if the unthinkable happens, there is someone else to do it.

by alpha, 1 year ago

I wasn't aware of that so I suppose I will have to put down both my brother and my sister in that case.

by frenchwoodgirl, 1 year ago

We did our will when the solicitors were offering them at a reduced cost and gave the proceeds to a local charity. They hold the original and won't see any more money out of us but was worth it, to ensure it was done properly.

by scottie, 1 year ago

I believe everyone and their professional service is set up for a reason.
You have no idea what the circumstances of your executor will be at that time or your relationship with that executor.

You need someone who will be middle ground and have no emotional attachment to your will.
- I would use a solicitor and a trusted source.

But, I do think the banks have a cheek., As if their billions aren't enough!- next, they'll be charging us for walking into their branches.

by Member-4345, 1 year ago

My experience tells me that people who agree to their bank drawing up their will and acting as executor only live to regret it. Banks are simply too corporate, too big and impersonal ever to actually worry about their image in such affairs. And I suggest that it gives the banks far too much control in the matter. It's just another money making avenue where the service is probably run entirely from a single corporate office somewhere remote and where identifying who is actually 'looking after you' will always be hard.

I still maintain that a properly solicitor led will with the executorship being split between a trusted family member and the solicitor is a good choice. Proper and sound legal handling will never be free but at least solicitors can be struck off should they do something wrong. Can that be said of banks?

by Snoopy48, 1 year ago

I agree, Snoops, and we all know banks are fireproof and untouchable, don't we!

by fruitcake, 1 year ago

Posts within the money.co.uk community represent the views, experiences and opinions of members only. They should not be taken as financial advice and should not be followed without further research.

Get our free money saving newsletter
Join over 480,000 other subscribers who grab our expert money tips, unmissable money guides & hottest bargains each week in our special email...

More Questions for Wills

Open Questions
Closed Questions
Join Our Community

Get fast answers to your money questions, Expert insight, top tips & much more...